A grading reference
How to grade a record's
condition.
Two records with the same catalog number and the same pressing can sell for ten times different prices because of condition. The Goldmine grading scale (used since the 1980s by Goldmine magazine and adopted broadly by Discogs and most US dealers) runs from Mint at the top to Poor at the bottom. Grading the sleeve and the vinyl separately is standard. The scale is straightforward once you know what each grade actually looks like under inspection.
01
The Goldmine scale, top to bottom
Eight grades, applied separately to the sleeve and to the vinyl. A typical eBay or Discogs listing reads like “Sleeve VG+ / Vinyl NM” — the sleeve grade always comes first.
| Grade | Vinyl looks like | Plays like |
|---|---|---|
| Mint (M) | Sealed, never opened, factory-fresh | N/A (don't play it) |
| Near Mint (NM or M-) | Glossy, no visible scratches, no marks under angled light | Silent surface, no audible defects |
| Very Good Plus (VG+) | Light surface marks, a faint hairline or two, glossy overall | Quiet between tracks, possibly a faint tick |
| Very Good (VG) | Visible scratches, light scuffs, dullness in spots | Audible surface noise between tracks, occasional pop |
| Good Plus (G+) | Significant scratches, scuffs, possible dull sections | Consistent surface noise, music still audible |
| Good (G) | Deep scratches, heavy wear, possible slight warping | Heavy noise but music plays through |
| Fair (F) | Major scratches, possible cracks, significant warping | Distortion, skipping, music partially audible |
| Poor (P) | Unplayable damage — cracks, deep gouges, severe warping | Won't play through |
Source: Goldmine Record Album Price Guide grading standard, adopted by Discogs and most US vinyl marketplaces.
02
How much condition moves the price
A first-press copy in NM trades for roughly 3–5× what the same pressing brings in VG condition, and about 1.5–2× the VG+ price. The premium accelerates as condition improves — going from G to VG is small, going from VG+ to NM is large.
For a $200 NM first-press of, say, an original Beatles album: a VG+ copy clears around $100–130, a VG copy around $40–60, a G copy around $15–25, and a Fair or Poor copy is worthless to a collector. A sealed Mint copy of the same record can push to $400–800+ when authenticated.
For a common $10 reissue: the spread is much narrower. NM is $10, VG+ is $7, VG is $4. The condition curve is steeper for valuable pressings because rarity and condition compound.
03
Grading the sleeve
The same scale applies to the album jacket, with different specific defects. The most common sleeve issues, in rough order of how much they cost:
Ringwear. The circular impression worn into the front cover where the record has been stored against the inner sleeve for decades. Almost every surviving 1960s and 1970s jacket has some degree of ringwear. NM-grade sleeves have none visible.
Seam splits. Splits along the bottom or side seam where the cover paper has separated from the cardboard backing. Common on heavy gatefold covers (Quadrophenia, Exile on Main St., Yes Fragile). Splits up to one inch are VG+ territory; longer splits drop to VG or below.
Water rings, stains, mold. Disqualifies a sleeve from the upper grades regardless of other condition. Even a faint coffee ring on the front cover drops a sleeve to VG or below.
Writing on the cover. Owner names, price tags, store stickers, “DJ COPY” stamps. Original promotional stamps add value; handwritten owner names cut it.
Tape and repairs. Tape always disqualifies a sleeve from the upper grades — even clear archival tape leaves residue and discoloration. Repaired splits drop a sleeve by at least one full grade.
04
How to grade in practice
Pull the record from the sleeve under good light. Hold it at an angle so a single light source reflects off the surface. The angled-reflection technique makes hairlines and surface marks visible that disappear under direct overhead light.
For the vinyl: rotate slowly under the angled light. Look at both sides. NM records reflect cleanly with no scratches visible at any angle. VG+ records have a few hairlines that catch the light but no deep scratches. VG records have visible scuffs and some dullness. Below VG, the defects are obvious without careful inspection.
For the sleeve: lay it flat under direct light. Check front and back for ringwear, seam splits, stains, and discoloration. Run a fingernail lightly along the seams to detect splits that haven't fully opened.
When uncertain, grade conservatively. A VG+ listing that arrives as VG generates a return; a VG listing that arrives as VG+ generates a happy buyer. Conservative grading builds the seller reputation that translates into higher sale prices over time.
05
If you have a stack to grade
Grading one record takes a couple of minutes. Grading a hundred takes a focused weekend. The bottleneck isn't the inspection — it's the writing down and the catalog management. Crown Vinyl scans each record from a photograph and prompts you for the condition grade, then saves both into a cloud-synced collection alongside the current value from recent real sales at that grade. Free on the App Store.
A few questions
The ones that come up.
Near Mint. A record one step below sealed-Mint condition. The vinyl is glossy with no visible scratches under angled light and plays with a silent surface and no audible defects. The sleeve has no ringwear, no seam splits, no writing, and no discoloration. NM is the highest grade for an opened record and typically trades at 1.5–2× the VG+ price.
VG+ records have a few faint hairlines visible under angled light and may produce an occasional tick during playback; NM records have no visible marks at any angle and play silently. The difference is subtle in appearance but meaningful in sale price — a VG+ first-press typically trades at 50–70% of the NM price for the same record.
The same Goldmine scale (M through P) applies. The grade reflects sleeve-specific defects: ringwear, seam splits, water stains, mold, owner writing, tape repairs. Standard listing format puts the sleeve grade first: 'Sleeve VG+ / Vinyl NM' indicates a slightly worn jacket with a clean record inside.
Both matter, but their weight depends on the buyer. Collectors who plan to display the album care about the sleeve; collectors who plan to play it care about the vinyl. For mainstream first-press copies, a mismatched-grade copy (NM vinyl in a VG sleeve, or vice versa) typically settles at the lower of the two grades' prices. For investment-grade rarities, an NM sleeve with a VG vinyl is often more valuable than the reverse because the sleeve is the harder thing to find clean.
Free to startNo adsPrivate by defaultCloud syncBuilt for iOS